Please vote for us, we need your support to continue offering such tools and services!

Should the Block Producers blacklist every account that has posted an unactionable referendum question?

dontbedumb by imblackbeard 14-January-2019 01:01:44 UTC

Poll status

58,999 EOS voted
YES= 0.1% YES NO= 99.9% NO

You voted {{(lastVote==1)?'YES':'NO'}}  

{{votingResponse.message}}

Post a public comment (optional)

Select Yes/No to cast your vote and make your comment public on the EOS blockchain. Your comment and vote will be recorded on-chain for ever, if you want to change your comment please vote again and our algorithm will attempt to just show your latest comment.

Account
{{ webdigiWallet.account.account_name}}
  • 23 accounts
  • 5 days since poll started
  • 0.01% participation
  • -100% YES lead over NO

Question

Should the Block Producers freeze the account of every person who has posted an unactionable referendum question?

Language of Record

The language of record for this Binding Referendum question is English.

Proposers

Branden Espinoza

Description of Referendum

Many in the EOS community are posting referendum questions that do not contain sufficient information for the Block Producers to execute. This referendum is intended to enable the Block Producers to blacklist accounts responsible for posting incomplete and irresponsible proposals.

Interpretive Statement

If this referendum passes, on the 1st and 15th of each month, Branden Espinoza (EOS Account: ImBlackbeard) will review all of the existing referenda of type referendum-v1 proposed via eosio.forum. He will decide if a given referendum is adequate complete, using the EOS BallotCraft Guide as the standard for Best Practices. He will issue a BLACKLIST ORDER via http://eos-forum.org that will indicate each account to be blacklisted.

Block Producer Instructions

Within 7 days of each BLACKLIST ORDER, the top 21 BPs shall blacklist every account identified.

Arguments & Rebuttals

Argument In Favor

Members of the EOS community are using the Binding Referendum tool to post incomplete and inactionable referendum questions. The integrity of the referendum system will be criticized when one of these inactionable questions passes by the threshholds identified in the EOS Interim Contitution and the BPs are forced to ignore it. This proposal protects the EOS mainnet from such criticism.

Rebuttal

There is a learning curve here. The community will understand if the BPs can't act on a given referendum.

Official Discussion Forum





Time Frame:








1 Comment

These comments were made along with their vote

Sort by...
  • Please use the BallotCraft Guide: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1IjcstNYlfyHNUoZj1eWv0Q60v7n4s2BA/view


Related Polls